Does Green Bring Green?

Does being green give companies a competitive advantage?

Look no further than WalMart, Clorox, Kimberly Clark, P&G, Ford or any other corporation that has developed green product lines or made investments in major sustainability initiatives.

And many companies with sustainability baked into their mission have had enormous growth despite a lousy economy—just see B Corporation’s Rockstars of the New Economy.

And research by the MIT Sloan Management Review and Boston Consulting Group provides direct evidence that sustainability delivers in measurable ways.

According to The Innovation Bottom Line report’s fourth annual survey of 4,000 executives and managers, 37 percent of respondents say sustainability added to profits, up 23 percent from the last survey. Direct benefits include:

  • Improved brand reputation
  • Better innovation of products and services
  • Improved perception of how the company is managed
  • Increased competitive advantage
  • Reduced costs from efficiencies in energy, waste, and materials
  • Better innovation of business models and processes

But to obtain these benefits, companies must make a commitment to sustainability. The survey researchers found that companies need to develop a business case for sustainability, and those that are most successful change their business model or have sustainability engrained in the company from the start. More than half of companies that changed their business model say customer demand for sustainability led to changes.

This is no surprise to us. Just see Zipcar, Method, Patagonia, the B Corp Rockstars and many others.

What about the other 63 percent of respondents? Many companies struggle with justifying sustainability initiatives, and 37 percent say sustainability conflicts with other priorities. One finding reveals that investors are a “challenging” stakeholder group because their horizon for profit is short.

In reviewing the successful companies, the survey researchers identified the following practices for sustainability success:

  1. Be prepared to change business models. Deep and engrained change is a clear indicator of whether sustainability initiatives will boost success.
  2. Lead from the top and integrate efforts. Executives must set goals and integrate sustainability into the business.
  3. Measure and track goals and performance. This one is a no-brainer.
  4. Understand what your customers think about sustainability and what they are willing to pay for it. They’re not always willing to pay more; you need to know.
  5. Collaborate with people, customers, and organizations beyond the organization. Sustainability efforts offer a real opportunity to know customers better, and many companies form advisory groups to guide these efforts.

Ultimately, what companies do matters if we are to create a better world that sustains us all—the research doesn’t examine altruistic motives. I’m not sure it needs to; good intentions aren’t going to build the next economy. And it’s clear that sustainability has become a business imperative. Sixty percent of The Innovation Bottom Line survey respondents say sustainability strategies are necessary to be competitive right now, and another 31 percent believe they will be in the future.

We’ll keep an eye on how businesses can achieve and maintain their sustainability advantage, and report back in future posts.

Benefit Corporation Movement Surges Across the Country

It’s been a little over a year since Thinkshift joined 12 other businesses to become one of the first California benefit corporations, and a lot has happened since then. A year ago, there were a few dozen benefit corporations, and California was the seventh state to pass the legislation. There are now more than 200 benefit corporations in the U.S. and the form is available in 12 states.

Growth prospects for 2013 are looking even stronger, said the founders of B Lab, the leading advocate for benefit corporation legislation, during a recent briefing to B Corps on the “State of the B.” (B Lab certifies companies as B Corporations, which meet high social and environmental performance standards. Thinkshift became a B Corp in 2010; today there are nearly 700 B Corps in 24 countries.)

Benefit corporation laws are pending in 17 more states—including Delaware, which would be huge. About half the country’s public companies, and 63 percent of Fortune 500 companies, are incorporated there. The governor and secretary of state want it—already, a couple of companies have left the state to become benefit corporations elsewhere—and the legislation is likely to pass this spring.

But it’s not going to be easy to get legislation with substance, according to B Lab’s Andrew Kassoy. The state bar is interested in maintaining the status quo, and there’s a good chance legislation will allow companies to greenwash, he said. Benefit corporation laws in other states specify that companies must benefit society, consider all stakeholders and report on their performance using a third-party standard. In Delaware, the state bar is pushing for legislation that would let companies do what they want (benefit society or something else), consider only certain stakeholders and self-report.

B Lab is working to keep Delaware from passing a watered-down law, with campaigns on care2.com and change.org and other actions. Most of the nearly 700 certified B Corporations will be signatories of a letter to the governor. To learn more, go to bcorporation.net.

B Corps Go International

Exciting news on the B Corporation front—the B Corp movement is expanding internationally.

B Lab, the nonprofit that certifies B Corps, is working with Santiago, Chile­­–based Sistema B to certify B Corps in South America. Sistema B is starting with companies in Chile, Argentina and Colombia. In just over three months in operation, the organization has gathered commitments from 100 entrepreneurs committed to becoming Empresas B Certificados.

B Lab sees Sistema B as a pilot program—it plans to learn from the organization’s successes and replicate the model in other parts of the world. Meanwhile, companies outside the U.S. can become B Corps through B Lab.

In the U.S., Illinois became the 10th state to establish benefit corporations Aug. 2 when the governor signed the Benefit Corporation Act into law. Legislation is pending in Michigan, Pennsylvania, Connecticut and North Carolina, and according to B Lab’s recent State of the B conference, B Corps in Oregon are organizing to push legislation forward.

Finally, a fun note to end this B Corp update: Etsy, the online craft marketplace, is one of the newest B Corps. As of the last count at B Lab, there are 574 Certified B Corps.

Our New Client: RSF Social Finance

We have long admired the work of RSF Social Finance, an organization that is transforming the way the world works with money. We are extremely proud to say that RSF is now a client! We’re working with them to help get their story out—or rather, their stories, which are incredibly rich and varied.

At a basic level, RSF provides loans and grants to social enterprises in food and agriculture, the environment, and education and the arts. Since 1984, they have made $285 million in loans and provided $109 million in grants. But their innovative work goes far beyond these numbers. RSF is a catalyst for social finance, working with organizations like B Lab and the Social Venture Network to build new models for doing business. RSF creates financial relationships among stakeholders that are direct, transparent and personal—adjectives not typically associated with finance as we know it.

One great example is RSF’s pricing meetings, begun in 2009, in which borrowers and investors discuss what’s happening with their money and work together to recommend interest rates. This creates a community working for mutual benefit rather than the typical adversarial relationship in which everyone seeks only their own advantage.

It seems fitting, or maybe ironic, that we’re celebrating our new relationship with RSF at a time when yet another story of financial misdeeds is in the headlines: Barclays’ chairman has resigned and the bank is paying a paltry $450 million to settle accusations that it manipulated interest rates to boost its bottom line at the expense of borrowers. The slightly bright side is that the Barclays affair is part of a wider investigation into the secretive and complex ways big banks set rates that affect borrowing costs.

It goes without saying that this is antithetical to RSF’s work, which is based in associative economics, a philosophy that considers all stakeholders’ needs. RSF’s transformative work is helping to build the next economy. We’ll keep you updated on their progress.

World Environment Day: How Are You Celebrating?

Today is World Environment Day!

This year’s theme is “Green Economy: Does It Include You?” You might wonder: “green economy” has become a buzz phrase in recent years, but what does it really mean? Well, according to the United Nations, a green economy is one that “results in improved human well-being and social equity, while significantly reducing environmental risks and ecological scarcities.”

Brazil is the host city this year and that’s no surprise. Brazil is a great supporter of the green energy industry and as a result has created many green jobs.  It goes to show that green spending definitely can boost the economy.

World Environment Day organizers are encouraging everyone to celebrate the day by undertaking a green economy–related activity sometime this week. At Thinkshift, we’re always working for the day when there is no difference between “economy” and “green economy,” so we thought, why not adopt a policy we can continue long term? On this World Environment Day, we commit to supporting other B Corps and benefit corporations by turning to them first when we need goods, services or partners.

How will you participate?  Visit http://www.unep.org/wed/aroundtheworld/ to find out more about World Environment Day.  Whatever you do, we hope that it becomes a sustainable habit and a part of your daily life.